Header graphic for print

Food Safety News

Breaking news for everyone's consumption

Plea Agreement Will Limit Lightsey’s Prison Time to Six Years at Most

Samuel Lightsey, the former processing plant manager for Peanut Corporation of America at Blakely, GA, entered guilty pleas late Wednesday to multiple federal felony counts stemming from the deadly 2008-2009 Salmonella outbreak.

Lightsey and the government reached a plea agreement for cooperation against other defendants in exchange for sentencing consideration to keep his prison term at no more than six years.

Samuel Lightsey (left) and Stewart Parnell appeared in February 2009 before a subcommittee of the House Energy and Commerce Committee but invoked the Fifth Amendment rather than respond to lawmakers’ questions.

Along with three other former executives of the now-defunct PCA, Lightsey pleaded not guilty in February 2013 on all 76 felony counts charged in a federal grand jury indictment. His plea agreement is similar to one the government reached with Daniel Kilgore at the time it was bringing those indictments. Kilgore was PCA’s operation manager at the Blakely, GA, plant from 2002-2008.

Both top managers are now available to the government as witnesses at the trial, scheduled to begin July 14. The remaining defendants are Stewart Parnell, PCA’s former chief executive officer; Michael Parnell, PCA’s former vice president and peanut broker, and Mary Wilkerson, PCA’s former manager of quality control.

While it is not known how long Lightsey’s Birmingham-based Parkman & White defense team might have been in negotiations with government attorneys, the change-of-plea hearing was announced with only about a day’s notice.

“Stewart Parnell is disappointed and saddened to learn that the two employees entrusted by PCA to manage the Blakely plant have acted contrary to clear policies set forth by PCA and, apparently, in violation of federal law,” defense attorney Scott Austin told Food Safety News. Austin heads the Roanoke, VA-based Gentry Locke trial team defending Parnell that also includes Tom Bondurant and Justin Lugar. His team still expects to go to trial.

“Stewart has not accepted a plea nor has he changed his plea,” Austin said.

Until he entered a guilty plea on Wednesday, Lightsey was going to trial this summer with the Parnells, who are brothers, on all federal felonies charged, including multiple counts of conspiracy, introduction of adulterated food into interstate commerce with intent to defraud or mislead, introduction of misbranded food into interstate commerce with intent to defraud or mislead, interstate shipments fraud, wire fraud and obstruction of justice. His role will now be that of a government witness.

Wilkerson is being tried at the same time for two counts of obstruction of justice.

All the charges followed a four-year FBI investigation into the 2008-2009 Salmonella outbreak that sickened at least 700 people and killed nine. The pathogen was sourced back to the peanut butters and paste produced by the Lynchburg, VA-based PCA at processing plants in Blakely, GA, and Plainview, TX. Government attorneys believe they can prove the executives knew that the product they shipped was contaminated.

UPDATE:  Now public court documents show Lightsey plead guilty on just seven  of the 76 counts that were in the original  indictment.  The seven  carry  maximum statutory penalties of 76 years in prison, fines of $1.75 million, and 17 years of supervised release.  In exchange for his cooperation, government attorneys are recommending Lightsey instead get no more than six years in prison with no fine amount mentioned.

The seven counts he has pleaded guilty on are: 1.) Conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud; 2.) Conspiracy to introduce adulterated and misbranded food into interstate commerce with intent to defraud; 3.) Introduction of adulterated food into interstate commerce with intent to defraud; 4.) Introduction of misbranded food into interstate commerce with the intent to defraud; 5.) Interstate shipments fraud; 6.) Wire fraud; and 7.)  and obstruction of justice.

In the plea agreement government attorneys say the “terminated” counts against Lightsey would have been proven beyond a reasonable doubt at trial, but the defendant lacks sufficient knowledge, information or belief to either admit or deny them.  Lightsey also waives certain appeal rights in the agreement.

He remains free on bond until sentencing and available to provide “complete, candid and truthful testimony regarding such matters in any proceeding.  Whether he provides “substantial assistance” to the government is not based on whether the others are convicted at trial.

Lightsey’s change of plea hearing took two hours to complete.   The sentencing date has not been set.










© Food Safety News
  • J

    This is a sad situation all the way around. That plant has not met standards for years because the Parnells would not spend money on basic maintenance and refused to pay for required testing to ensure the product was safe. The product that contained salmonella was ordered to be shipped without getting or waiting on test results. Unfortunately, Mr. Lightsey was not prepared for the situation he stepped into. He had taken the job six months earlier to be home with this family. It is tragic for the people who lost their lives and were sickened by the salmonella. It is unfortunate that the owners would not allow the facility to be operated to the proper standards which ended in the closing of the facility in a small town with negative growth and limited job opportunities. I sincerely hope that the Parnells do not have enough money to buy their way out of prison.

    • Oginikwe

      Hardly fair for Lightsey to be made a fall guy but he had to know that when he went along with the Parnell’s agenda that would happen. At least his family is still alive which is more than can be said for nine people.

  • Jessica

    Put them away! Too many companies are getting away with shipping out contaminated food! If this keeps happening, we’ll end up like China. No oversight in mass production due to greed. Looks like we are walking that line already