Header graphic for print

Food Safety News

Breaking news for everyone's consumption

Q&A With Temple Grandin Part II

As part of our ongoing expert Q&A series, a conversation with

world-renowned livestock expert Temple Grandin on humane handling,

small vs. big, transparency, and the future of agriculture

Temple Grandin has been a thought leader in both the animal agriculture

and autism realms for decades. Grandin, the world’s most well-known

autistic person, is a New York Times best-selling author, a professor

of animal science, a consultant to the leading food companies, and a

noted speaker on animal behavior and autism. She attributes her success

in improving humane handling systems for livestock, systems that now

impact around half the cattle in North America, to her different way of

thinking. “As a person with autism, it is easy for me to understand how

animals think because my thinking processes are like an animal’s,” she

says. Earlier this year, Grandin was named a “Hero” among TIME

Magazine’s 100 most influential people and was the subject of the HBO

film Temple Grandin, starring Claire Danes.

Food Safety News recently sat down with Grandin to discuss meat production and humane handling.

Part I of the interview,  discussing big vs. small ag and the need for more transparency in the meat system appeared in Food Safety News yesterday.

Part II

Q: So much of what we do see are the really bad

examples, the undercover whistleblower stuff…the veal in Vermont, the

recent dairy incident…

A: That was horrible, horrible, just horrible. That guy [from Conklin dairy] also has felony charges on an illegal gun.

Q: Are these isolated incidents?

A: Most

places are not doing stuff that horrible. To say that every dairy

treats their animals that way, no, that’s wrong, they’re not. But on

the other hand, the truth is usually somewhere in the middle, between

the animal rights advocates that say everything is an atrocity, to thetemple-grandin2-featured.jpg

industry who says everything’s just fine. I’ve worked in a lot of

places. It’s somewhere in the middle. It’s a constant battle. You can’t

under staff and overwork. Tired people are more likely to get angry,

and so are overworked people.

Q: What about high turnover?

A: Well,

if you treat the people decently you want have such high turnover. I

was horrified to find out about a dairy that was working its Mexican

employees 12 hours a day and not giving them lunch breaks, that’s just

terrible. I think we have to have more customers getting involved. I

just read something about people jumping off the roof in some factory

in China. Well, whosever electronics electronic doo-dads are getting

made in that factory, those companies need to go into those factories

and straighten this out. That’s unacceptable. Customers drive change.

Q:

Knowing what you know, are there certain things that you avoid, do you

understand the difficulties consumers face trying to make sense of all

of this?

A: I’m very concerned about what I call

biological system overload. We’re pushing chickens, turkeys, dairy

cows, and other animals to where they’re falling apart. We’re seeing

lameness and abnormal growth problems. Beef cattle still live outside

so we haven’t messed them up.

Q: Do you think that affects us?

A:

No, no I don’t think it affects us. A lot of people think chickens are

fed hormones and they’re not. The chickens just grow really fast

because they’ve been bred to grow really fast. It’s genetics. Same

thing with turkeys.

Q: Do you have confidence in the way we raise, slaughter, and process meat?

A: When

it’s done right, yeah. Things have to be done right. You’ve got to

figure out critical control points are really important, and you’ve got

to do it right. 

Q: Do you take issue with the subtherapeutic use of antibiotics in animal feed?

A:

The thing that’s not known, when it comes to antibiotics in feed, is

that a lot of it comes out the backside of the animal. What does that

do? It’s a massive, uncontrolled experiment. I’m not worried about

eating the meat, that doesn’t worry me. The meat’s fine. With the

antibiotics you’ve got science and nature…I’m reading a ton of red

flags. I’m going to call them red flags at this point.

Let’s

look real sensible into the future… There’s things that big Ag can

learn from organic. In the future, there will be a new large scale type

of commercial agriculture. We’re still going to use chemicals, we’re

still going to use antibiotics, but we’re going to use a whole lot less of them.

We’re going to adopt some of these crop rotation practices, get rid of

some of the monoculture and kind of make a new large-scale commercial

that will be economical. But, as long as corn and oil are cheap, this

no economic incentive to change.

Somewhere in the middle I can

see some kind of a hybrid thing forming. Right now, big Ag looks at

Michael Pollan as being kind of evil. Well I say, ‘there’s a lot of

things that Michael Pollan and you agree on, have you ever actually

read the book?’

© Food Safety News
  • http://edibleintelligence.blogspot.com/ Sam Vance

    There’s a funny myth that crop rotation will eliminate the need for fertilizers. Organic farmers brag about how they do common sense things like crop rotation, which goes a long way in reducing fertilizer use. Farmers have been rotating crops for decades. This isn’t new and the organic farmers didn’t corner the market on it.

  • Doc Mudd

    Playing to her public, Grandin gently stokes myths about agriculture but carefully stops short of promoting myths about autism. Celebrity, duplicity and ego may get the better of her – I sincerely hope not.

  • Meow

    Grandin isn’t an animal welfare advocate. (Not really) She’s merely helped to create better methods for slaughtering them for human consumption. When you go to the doctor to have a tooth pulled we use better methods now, than say 100 years ago. Same thing, the animals will get to buy the farm, but at least the methodology behind it is more humane.
    I’m a little concerned Ms.Grandin doesn’t offer more insight into ways of reducing the amount needed for slaughter than her concern for their treatment beforehand. She doesn’t really have to my knowledge on the whys of autism but does make some great suggestions to families on exposing kids to more and more stimuli to help reduce behaviors. That’s basic psychology 101, every one knows the old conditioning methods. Think Pavlov’s dog–it’s the basic tenet behind ABA.