Header graphic for print
Food Safety News Breaking news for everyone's consumption

Valley Meat Goes to Court to Get Equine Inspection Services

It’s possible USDA might like getting told by a federal judge that it must provide equine inspection services to Valley Meat Co. in Roswell, NM. That way, it couldn’t be blamed for the decision, which is likely to remain unpopular with many horse lovers.

More than a year after Congress lifted a ban on horse slaughter for human consumption in the U.S., the USDA has yet to provide any equine inspection services as the law would require it to do for any qualified applicant.

Rick de los Santos, owner of Valley Meat Co. in Roswell, NM, has an application pending with USDA Food Safety and Inspection Services (FSIS) to provide equine inspection to his company. Valley Meat for 20 years slaughtered beef cattle under USDA inspection. Now it wants to slaughter horses for human consumption.

After months of waiting, however, de los Santos sued FSIS for dragging its feet. He blames politics, and says the delays are costing his company thousands of dollars. To up the ante, de los Santos has also filed a defamation lawsuit against the Humane Society of the United States, Front Range Equine Rescue, and Animal Protection of New Mexico.

Those are among the organizations that don’t want to see horse slaughter resumed in the United States, and they sometimes come up with harsh commentary for companies that want to get into the business.

Horse slaughter, common worldwide, has always made Americans queasy because horses are seen more as companions to people than mere farm animals. Congress let the five-year ban on horse slaughter expire.

Speaking at the Southwest Meat Association last summer, FSIS Administrator Al Almanza said the agency would be ready to accommodate the inspection of horse slaughter operations by the end of 2012.

FSIS has to formally respond to the Valley Meat lawsuit in January.

© Food Safety News
  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IHEXYW5X74N4INHYYP7FINOPXY Frank

    While  I don’t think I would want to consume horse meat myself I can’t see wasting the resource for just dog food when people can benefit from this presumably lower cost protein source.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000986704697 Kathy Heinisch

     Maybe the tons & tons of offal Valley Meat left piled up rotting in the sun for 2 yrs has something to do it..as well as the violation for inhumane slaughter..                                                                                                             
    Valley Meats Disputes State Fine For Improper Cow Disposal

    By
    News Desk | August 29, 2012

    New Mexico’s Valley Meat Co. is appealing a state fine of $86,400 for improper disposal of composted cattle remains.
    The
    New Mexico Environment Department issued a compliance order Aug 2,
    citing Valley Meat for failure to register as a compositing facility for
    property located near the slaughterhouse, and for failing to properly
    dispose of solid waste.
    Valley Meat received the order and notice about the fine by e-mail on
    Aug. 14. Company attorney A. Blair Dunn said Valley Meat would file an
    appeal and request a hearing by state officials.

  • http://burningbird.net Shelley Powers

    After looking at the legal documents, I don’t think HSUS et al or the USDA have much to worry about. 

    Especially when you consider the fact that the owner of the plant withdrew his request for inspection months ago. 

    For those wanting comic relief, following are links to court documents (PDFs):

    Complaint against USDA:

    http://docs.burningbird.net/valleymeat-vs-usda-complaint.pdf

    Amended complaint against HSUS et al:http://docs.burningbird.net/valleymeat-vs-usda-complaint.pdf

    HSUS motion to dismiss (quickest one I have ever seen filed):http://docs.burningbird.net/valleymeat-vs-hsus-dismiss.pdf
    Valley Meat’s response to the motion to dismiss–my personal favorite of the bunch:http://docs.burningbird.net/valleymeat-vs-hsus-dismiss-reply.pdf

  • Sandra Force

    This idea that all horses are toxic is about as accurate as saying all vegetables are toxic because they grow under the sun.  Not all horses are given banned substances, in fact many are never given any of the drugs that require withdrawl periods.  Should they have to comply with standards?  Absolutely.  Should people have the right to refuse to sell for meat?  Absolutely.  Should people have the right to tell others how they can make their living, how they can dispose of livestock, what they can eat?  Absolutely NOT!!!!!