Header graphic for print

Food Safety News

Breaking news for everyone's consumption

FDA Asks Judge to Shut Down Juice Maker

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced Thursday that it wants to stop Hank J. Hagen and Milton S. Reid and their Jamaica, NY-based operation from processing and distributing juice.

At FDA’s request, the U.S. Department of Justice filed a complaint seeking an injunction against Hagen, Reid, and their company, which has gone by the names Mystical One LLC and Mystical One Juice LLC.

They are charged with violating the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act by failing to have a Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point (HACCP) plan for certain juice products, such as the company’s carrot juice products, and by failing to comply with current Good Manufacturing Practice (cGMP).

The FDA requires all juice processors to prepare and implement HACCP plans that identify and control food hazards associated with their juices, and it requires all food manufacturers to follow cGMP. 

The FDA is not aware of illnesses associated with Mystical One’s juice products.

Among the violations observed by FDA investigators were failures to: 

  • adequately heat low-acid vegetable juices to destroy or prevent growth of dangerous microorganisms; 

  • properly clean food-contact surfaces; and

  • maintain and monitor sanitation conditions at the manufacturing facility to prevent sources of possible food and water contamination.

Failure to identify and control food hazards could lead to the formation of Clostridium botulinum bacteria that can germinate in the carrot juice made by the company. 

The neurotoxin formed by these bacteria, when ingested in even very small amounts, could cause paralysis, difficulty breathing and death from asphyxiation.  In 2006, six cases of botulism in the United States and Canada were linked to refrigerated carrot juice.

The complaint also charges Mystical One, Hagen and Reid with failing to conform to cGMP requirements for making, packing, or holding human food.  Beverage products produced under conditions that do not comply with HACCP or GMP requirements are considered adulterated.

Violations cited by the FDA involved the following brands: 

  • Fresh Carrot Juice, 

  • Magnum Food Drink, 

  • Pineapple Ginger Drink, 

  • Sorrel & Ginger, 

  • Sea Moss, and 

  • Peanut Punch. 

The company purchases ingredients, such as carrots, that originate outside of New York and sells products to food service establishments primarily in New York, Connecticut and Pennsylvania.

The FDA’s most recent inspection at the Mystical One facility in August 2010 found the same or similar violations observed during previous inspections of the company. 

The agency issued a warning letter to the company in October 2009 and the company agreed to bring its operations into compliance.  However, Mystical One did not make the necessary changes, the FDA said.

“This action shows that FDA will take strong enforcement action against companies that fail to put the required preventive controls in place to protect their customers from foodborne illness,” said associate commissioner for Regulatory Affairs Dara A. Corrigan.  “Mystical One failed to adhere to food safety guidelines and we have stopped their operation.”

Loretta E. Lynch, U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of New York, together with the Department of Justice’s Office of Consumer Litigation, filed the injunction. 
 It will be up to a federal judge whether to put the juice maker out of business.

© Food Safety News
  • Marygrace

    This was in this morning’s 1/14/11 Food Safety News. Based on our conversation I thought you might find it useful.
    Jesse Salafia