Header graphic for print

Food Safety News

Breaking news for everyone's consumption

Congress Grills the Iowa Egg Execs

In a blockbuster-worthy hearing, complete with partisan bickering, a photo slideshow, and a witness pleading the Fifth, Congress yesterday grilled the executives responsible for two Iowa egg farms linked to over 1,600 illnesses.

Though Jack DeCoster, who owns the company at the center of the investigation, apologized to anyone “who may have been sickened by eating our eggs,” he and his son, Peter, who now runs the Iowa facility, were met with tough questioning from lawmakers.

“You have a history of over 30 years of Salmonella in eggs and a pretty sordid record,” said Rep. Henry Waxman (D-CA), chairman of the Energy and Commerce Committee, after a series of U.S. Food and Drug Administration photos of the facilities were shown. “Your facilities were not clean, they were not sanitary. They were filthy. You are a habitual violator of safety standards.”

Rep. Edward Markey (D-MA) echoed a similar sentiment: “Mr. DeCoster clearly has no regard for regulations until the point at which he actually gets caught,” he said. Markey also compared the conditions at the Iowa farms to the revelations in Upton Sinclair’s “The Jungle.”

Jack DeCoster, his voice shaky at times, said that the history of violations were “complicated.” He and his son Peter disputed some of the FDA’s findings in their inspection report. They blamed Iowa weather for causing a backup in the removal of manure, causing the pile up cited by inspectors. They also said they believe the contamination likely originated in a bone meal ingredient they sourced for their chicken feed.

FDA officials maintain that the feed is only one of many possible ways Salmonella bacteria could have entered the Iowa facilities. The dozens of positive environmental tests, rodents, loose chickens, and open piles of manure the FDA found make it difficult to pinpoint the mode of contamination.

Orlando Bethel, president of Hillandale Farms of Iowa, was also on the list of witnesses but pleaded the Fifth before the committee, declining to answer any questions from lawmakers. In lieu of Bethel, the company’s production representative, Duane Mangskau, testified.

The Energy and Commerce Committee’s Subcommittee on Government Oversight and Investigations heard emotional testimony from victims, whose Salmonella infections were positively linked to the multistate outbreak and traced to the Iowa egg farms.

Sarah Lewis, a 30-year-old mother and wife from California, told her story and called for more regulation of the egg industry.  She became violently ill after eating tarts served at a graduation party and ended up in Intensive Care. “Your whole body from head to toe is in agony,” she said.

The three and a half hour long hearing–full of traditional political theater and dozens of repeated questions–was kept lively with some partisan outbursts.  Members of the panel dueled over the Senate food safety legislation, which has remained stalled for over a year.

“Please lift your hold and allow this vital safety legislation to move forward,” said Waxman, appealing to Senator Tom Coburn (R-OK), who has objected to moving the food safety bill forward under Majority Leader Harry Reid’s (D-NV) rules for debate. Waxman joined several other panel members in appealing to the Oklahoma Republican to remove his hold.

When ranking member Michael Burgess (R-TX), who supports the food safety legislation, tried to submit a Coburn statement to the record he was shut down by the Democrats in the room.  When he continued to object, subcommittee chairman Bart Stupak (D-MI) turned off his microphone.

For more of the most colorful moments of the hearing, see the Food Safety News twitter stream: http://twitter.com/foodsafetynews

© Food Safety News
  • http://www.healthyfoodcoalition.org hhamil

    Michael Taylor, Deputy Commissioner for Food at the FDA was listed as the only FDA witness as of the morning of the hearing but Joshua Sharfstein, Principal Deputy Commissioner of the FDA testified. Why the change? Does the Deputy Commissioner for Food NOT oversee the Final Egg Rule and its implementation?
    Was Sharfstein not also “grilled” for the FDA’s poor performance in implementing its Final Egg Rule?
    My guess is that your paragraph below tells us the most about what the primary purpose of this “hearing” was, namely, drumming up support for the passage of the managers’ version of S 510. I thought this hearing was to investigate what happened in this outbreak.
    “When ranking member Michael Burgess (R-TX), who supports the food safety legislation, tried to submit a Coburn statement to the record he was shut down by the Democrats in the room. When he continued to object, subcommittee chairman Bart Stupak (D-MI) turned off his microphone.”
    A supporter of the food safety legislation wasn’t able to counter the political theater being created. So much for support of free speech in the U. S. House of Representatives.

  • http://www.healthyfoodcoalition.org Harry Hamil

    Michael Taylor, Deputy Commissioner for Food at the FDA was listed as the only FDA witness as of the morning of the hearing but Joshua Sharfstein, Principal Deputy Commissioner of the FDA testified. Why the change? Does the Deputy Commissioner for Food NOT oversee the Final Egg Rule and its implementation?
    Was Sharfstein not also “grilled” for the FDA’s poor performance in implementing its Final Egg Rule?
    My guess is that your paragraph below tells us the most about what the primary purpose of this “hearing” was, namely, drumming up support for the passage of the managers’ version of S 510. I thought this hearing was to investigate what happened in this outbreak.
    “When ranking member Michael Burgess (R-TX), who supports the food safety legislation, tried to submit a Coburn statement to the record he was shut down by the Democrats in the room. When he continued to object, subcommittee chairman Bart Stupak (D-MI) turned off his microphone.”
    A supporter of the food safety legislation wasn’t able to counter the political theater being created. So much for support of free speech in the U. S. House of Representatives.

  • arthur

    Living in the U.S. one of the most powerful and influencial countries on the planet I think it’s outragous what has taken place here. I am ashamed and I k not what our four fathers had planned for our nation of free individuals. “Freedom,” this word was not meant to be taken so literally and should be looked on more closely, specially with these huge coorporations. In addition,I think that democrats and republicans should make up their minds for once for what is best for the American people, instead of themselves.